Best HSA Providers 2026:
Fidelity vs Lively vs HSA Bank vs HealthEquity
By
Oran Furman
We read each provider's own fee schedule, rate sheet and investing page so you can see what an HSA really costs, what it pays and who it fits.
Bottom Line Up Front: Fidelity fits most individuals: $0 account fees, no investing minimum and a 3.56% cash yield, though that cash is not FDIC-insured. Pick HSA Bank for FDIC-insured cash with low-cost managed investing, Lively for a simple no-fee account, and HealthEquity if your employer uses it and covers the fees.
The 2026 HSA Comparison Matrix
| Feature | Fidelity | Lively | HSA Bank | HealthEquity |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly fee (individual) | $0. Fidelity lists zero account fees and zero minimums. | $0 monthly, opening and closing. | $0 with e-statements; $1.50 a month if you keep paper statements. | $2.95 a month, waived if your HSA cash balance is over $2,000 on the first day of the month. |
| If your employer offers it | Employer pays a recordkeeping fee of up to $48 a year and may pass it on. | Employers pay $0 per employee with a $200 monthly minimum. Free to you if you choose Lively yourself. | Fees may vary based on your employer relationship (per HSA Bank's fee schedule). | Employers may cover all or part of the fee. |
| Closing fee | None listed. Fidelity advertises zero account fees. | $0 | $25 | $25 |
| Cash interest | 3.56% 7-day yield on the default money market fund (as of Oct 4, 2026) | Standard: 0.02% (under $2,500) rising to 0.12% ($10,001+). Optional HSA Boost: 0.15% to 1.06%, not FDIC-insured. | 0.05% under $5,000; 0.15% from $5,000; 0.30% from $25,000; 0.50% from $50,000. | Basic Rates (FDIC/NCUA-insured) or Enhanced Rates (annuity, not insured). Enhanced default was 0.10% on a $2,000 balance (Oct 4, 2026). |
| Yearly interest on $2,500 cash | About $89 (at 3.56%; the yield floats) | About $0.50 standard, about $3.75 with Boost | About $1.25 | About $2.50 (Enhanced, 0.10%) |
| Is the cash FDIC-insured? | No (default sweep is money market fund FDRXX) | Yes, up to $250,000 through partner banks (standard); Boost is not | Yes | Basic Rates yes; Enhanced Rates no |
| Minimum to invest | None | None | A minimum cash balance may be required; the amount is not published (Morningstar says the minimum was removed in 2026). | An investment threshold applies; Morningstar's 2025 report put it at $500. |
| Investment menu | Stocks, ETFs and mutual funds with fractional shares. Fidelity Go robo: $0 under $25,000, 0.35% above, $10 minimum. | Schwab brokerage ($24/yr, waived with $3,000 cash) or Guided Portfolio at 0.50% a year plus about 0.23% in fund costs. | HSA Invest: Choice (brokerage) 0.10%, Select (RIA-picked funds) 0.25%, Managed 0.35% a year, waived in any quarter with $7,500+ average cash. | 33 Vanguard funds. 0.03% a month admin fee (max $10) on all options; AutoPilot and GPS add 0.05% a month (max $15). |
| Illustrative yearly cost ($2,500 cash, $20,000 invested) | $0 plus fund expenses | $24 Schwab, or $100 Guided | $20 Choice, $50 Select, $70 Managed | About $72 (Self-Driven), about $192 with AutoPilot or GPS |
| Debit card | Available; fees not published on its HSA page. | Up to 3 cards free; no ATM or cash access. | Available; $5,000 daily limit. | First 3 cards free; $5 each extra or replacement. |
| Reimbursing yourself | Pay out of pocket, reimburse from HSA, keep receipts. | $0 reimbursement fee. | Online or in the app, no receipt submission. | Electronic free; $2.00 for a paper check. |
| Transfers in | Accepted any time. | $0 to transfer in or out. | No fee; direct transfers free and unlimited, rollovers once per 12 months. | Double interest promo on transfers or rollovers of $250+. |
| Morningstar 2026 rating (spending / investing) | High / Average | Above Average / Average | Above Average / High | Above Average / Above Average |
Figures are from each provider's own pages unless labeled. Yearly cost and interest lines are our arithmetic from published rates and exclude fund expense ratios.
Strategic 2026 Wizard Insights
The cash gap is huge
On a $2,500 balance Fidelity's 3.56% sweep earns roughly $89 a year, while the others pay about $1 to $4. The catch: that cash sits in a money market fund, not an FDIC-insured account, and its yield moves with rates. If you spend your HSA regularly and want insured cash, expect near-zero interest.
Know the thresholds
HSA Bank waives investing fees in any quarter your average cash is $7,500+. Lively waives its $24 Schwab fee at $3,000 in cash. HealthEquity waives its $2.95 monthly fee above $2,000. Cash balance rules matter more than headline fees.
You are not locked in
Your employer picks where payroll contributions go, but you can transfer the balance to any custodian. HSA Bank charges nothing to receive a transfer, Lively and Fidelity accept transfers, and the main cost is your old custodian's closing fee (HealthEquity charges $25).
What Morningstar says
Morningstar's 2026 HSA Landscape (Sept 23, 2026) rated Fidelity High for spending, HSA Bank High for investing (first time), and HealthEquity Above Average on both. Disclosure: HSA Bank is the HSA provider for Morningstar's own employees, which Morningstar notes as a potential conflict.
Provider-by-Provider Breakdown
Fidelity HSA
- Fees: $0 account fees and $0 minimums for individuals; employer-linked accounts can carry up to $48 a year in recordkeeping fees.
- Cash: new accounts default to Fidelity Government Cash Reserves (FDRXX). It is a money market fund, not FDIC-insured. Yield was 3.56% as of Oct 4, 2026.
- Investing: stocks, ETFs and mutual funds with no minimum. Fidelity Go (robo) charges $0 under $25,000 and 0.35% above, $10 to start.
- Open to anyone; you need an HSA-eligible health plan only to contribute.
- Watch for: money market cash is not bank-insured; fund expense ratios still apply.
Lively HSA
- Fees: $0 for maintenance, opening, closing, transfers, reimbursements and up to three debit cards (no ATM or cash access).
- Cash: standard rates run 0.02% to 0.12% by balance, FDIC-insured up to $250,000 through partner banks. HSA Boost pays 0.15% to 1.06% but is not FDIC-insured. Rate sheet dated Aug 2025; Lively's Sept 2026 page cites the same ranges.
- Investing: no minimum. Schwab brokerage costs $24 a year, waived with $3,000 in cash. Guided Portfolio costs 0.50% a year plus fund costs.
- Watch for: the highest managed-portfolio fee in this group and very low standard interest.
HSA Bank
- Fees: $0 account summary with e-statements, $1.50 a month for paper, $25 to close. No minimum balance to open. HSA Bank is a division of Santander Bank, N.A., Member FDIC.
- Cash: 0.05% under $5,000, 0.15% from $5,000, 0.30% from $25,000, 0.50% from $50,000. These are the rates on the schedule HSA Bank links today (effective Oct 1, 2022).
- Investing: Choice 0.10%, Select 0.25%, Managed 0.35% a year, waived in any quarter with $7,500+ average cash. Real-time and fractional share trading.
- Transfers: no fee to receive; direct transfers unlimited, rollovers once per 12 months.
- Watch for: low cash rates and a minimum cash balance to invest that is not published.
HealthEquity
- Fees: $2.95 monthly, waived above $2,000 cash; $25 closing; $20 stop payment and excess contribution correction; $2.00 paper reimbursement check; 3 debit cards free, then $5 each. Schedule version 2025-11-18.
- Cash: Basic Rates (FDIC or NCUA-insured) or Enhanced Rates (group annuity, not insured). Rates are shown after login; Fidelity's comparison listed 0.10% for Enhanced on $2,000 (Oct 4, 2026).
- Investing: 33 Vanguard mutual funds; 0.03% monthly admin fee (max $10); AutoPilot and GPS advisory add 0.05% monthly (max $15). Cash Replenish sells investments when cash falls $50 below your threshold.
- Scale and app: 10.6M HSAs and $36.5B assets (FY ended Jan 31, 2026); iOS app rated 4.3 from 15,000 ratings (Sept 2026).
- Watch for: monthly fee below $2,000 cash and a threshold before you can invest.
Fidelity
The Investor's Pick$0 account fees, no investing minimum and a cash sweep yielding 3.56% (7-day yield, Oct 4, 2026). The only provider Morningstar rated High for spending in 2026. Cash is held in a money market fund, so it is not FDIC-insured.
Open a Fidelity HSA →Lively
The Zero-Fee Challenger$0 monthly, opening, closing and transfer fees for individuals, plus up to three free debit cards. Standard FDIC-insured cash pays only 0.02% to 0.12%, and Schwab investing costs $24 a year unless you hold $3,000 in cash.
See Lively →HSA Bank
The FDIC-Insured OptionFDIC-insured cash, no fee with e-statements, and the HSA Invest menu at 0.10% to 0.35% a year, waived in any quarter your average cash is $7,500+. Morningstar rated its investing High in 2026 (a division of Santander Bank).
See HSA Bank →HealthEquity
The Employer GiantThe largest custodian: 10.6 million HSAs and $36.5B in assets. A $2.95 monthly fee is waived above $2,000 in cash, and 33 Vanguard funds are available once you pass the investment threshold.
See HealthEquity →Frequently Asked Questions
Real answers to the questions people actually ask.
What are the 2026 HSA contribution limits?
Can I open an HSA without my employer?
Is my HSA cash FDIC-insured?
Which HSA pays the most interest on cash?
Can I have more than one HSA?
Do HSA fees depend on my balance?
Methodology
Figures come from each provider's own fee schedule, rate sheet and investing page, read on November 9, 2026, with each rate dated where the provider dates it. Where a provider shows rates only after login, we cite the most recent published figure and say so. Fidelity's comparison of HealthEquity and HSA Bank rates is a competitor source. Yearly cost and interest lines are our own arithmetic. Rates and fees change.
- Fidelity HSA: fees, cash yield and comparison
- Lively HSA pricing
- Lively HSA interest rates
- HSA Bank fee and interest rate schedule
- HSA Bank HSA Invest options and pricing
- HealthEquity schedule of fees
- HealthEquity HSA investment options
- HealthEquity interest rate and cash options
- IRS Rev. Proc. 2025-19 (2026 HSA limits)
- Morningstar 2026 HSA Landscape